Alzheimer's Disease and other Dementias
Walking Speed While Carrying a Tray or Counting Backwards May Help Diagnose a Reversible Form of Dementia
There’s a cause of dementia that can sometimes be reversed, but it’s often not diagnosed because the symptoms are so similar to those of other disorders. Now researchers say a simple walking test may be able to accurately diagnose the disease, according to a study published in the February 21st 2018 online issue of Neurology®, the medical journal of the American Academy of Neurology.
A release from the academy explains that the test involves seeing how fast a person can walk while doing something else at the same time, such as counting backwards or carrying a tray. The study found that the walking test may help differentiate between whether someone has idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus or progressive supranuclear palsy.
Idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus (iNPH), caused by excess fluid in the brain, can often be reversed but it is usually not diagnosed because it shares symptoms like walking, balance and thinking problems with other neurologic conditions, primarily progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP), which is caused by damage to nerve cells in the brain. There is no cure for PSP, but treatment may help ease symptoms.
The release quotes study author Charlotte Selge, MD, of the Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich in Germany as saying, “It is important that people with idiopathic normal pressure hydrocephalus are accurately diagnosed so they can be treated, and their health can improve. A simple walking test may help determine if a person has iNPH or PSP relatively early in the course of the disease. Our study found that adding another task while someone walks, and evaluating how it affects their walking ability, improves accuracy of the diagnosis.”
The study involved 27 people with iNPH, 38 people with PSP, and 38 healthy people of similar sex and age. Those with PSP and healthy controls had an average age of 69. Those with iNPH had an average age of 72. All participants received a complete neurologic exam, eye exam, MRI as well as thinking and memory tests. All were able to walk at least 30 feet without a walker or cane.
Researchers assessed participants’ manner of walking, or gait, by having all participants walk on a pressure-sensitive carpet that was 22 feet long. People were first asked to walk at three different speeds: slow, their preferred speed and as fast as possible. They were then asked to walk and count backwards at the same time and after that, to walk while carrying a tray.
Researchers found that walking while counting backwards resulted in a greater reduction of walking speed in those with PSP than in those with iNPH. Walking speed was reduced by 34 percent in those with PSP and by 17 percent in those with iNPH. When walking while carrying a tray, gait worsened for those with PSP but actually improved for those with iNPH, which may mean the dual-task test wasn’t challenging enough for those with iNPH, Selge said.
“People with PSP appear to be more sensitive to these dual-task walking tests than people with iNPH,” said Selge.
By just assessing walking, researchers were able to accurately diagnose who had PSP and who had iNPH 82 percent of the time. But when adding both dual-task tests to the assessment, diagnostic accuracy increased to 97 percent.
“Our findings suggest that adding these dual-task tests would be an inexpensive and effective way to improve diagnosis of iNPH,” said Selge. “Future studies may want to increase the complexity of tasks to see if they provide even more accuracy as well as insight into how the two diseases affect gait.”